February 13, 2024
5 minutes

Navigating the Maze: A Strategic Approach to Selecting the Ideal AI Transcription Tool


In the fast-paced realm of digital innovation, finding the perfect AI transcription tool can be a daunting task. As an agency, we don’t just have to identify cutting-edge solutions but also ensure that they are aligned with our clients’ specific needs. In this blog post, we’ll delve into our experience conducting a technical discovery to uncover the most suitable AI transcription service for a client's unique requirements.

Problem Statement and Objectives

Our primary challenge revolved around sourcing an AI transcription tool capable of accurately transcribing 1:1 conversations while adhering to stringent healthcare data regulations in Canada. The objective was clear – we needed to find a tool that not only met these specific criteria but also excelled in the field of medical terminology.


Our approach was meticulous, and involved:

  1. Market Exploration: We cast a wide net, exploring the market to identify potential candidates.
  2. Vendor Discussions: Engaging in meaningful conversations with various vendors to understand their offerings and capabilities.
  3. Use Case Testing: Rigorous testing of 8 different tools using scenarios and audio samples specific to the medical field. This included diverse conditions such as conversations over the phone, in-person, and via video calls, accounting for variables like background noise, mask-wearing and accents.

The Process: Identify Your Selection Criteria

Our journey yielded valuable insights that can hopefully help guide you through the labyrinth of AI transcription tool selection. Outlined below are some non-negotiable criteria that you may want to consider. 

Error Rate

To determine your acceptable error rate, consider the impact of errors on your specific use case. An example of a use case would be in the legal field, where a low error rate is essential. Misinterpretation of legal terms or statements could have serious consequences. Thus, an acceptable error rate for this use case might be as low as 0.5%, ensuring the fidelity of transcribed legal conversations.

Real-time vs Post-interaction

Assess whether real-time transcription is necessary, as it often comes at a higher cost compared to post-interaction processing. In live event scenarios, such as conference calls or webinars, real-time transcription is essential. The immediacy allows participants to follow discussions seamlessly. In contrast, for archival purposes or post-event analysis, post-interaction processing might be sufficient, reducing overall costs.

Multilingual Support

If needed, prioritize languages based on your target audience. Consider the specific linguistic landscape of your region.For a multinational corporation conducting business in regions with diverse languages, a transcription tool offering comprehensive multilingual support is indispensable. Prioritizing languages based on the target audience ensures accurate transcriptions across communication channels, supporting effective cross-cultural communication.


You should determine if redaction features, such as Personally Identifiable Information (PII) or Protected Health Information (PHI) removal, are necessary for your use case. In the legal or financial sector, where sensitive information like PII or PHI must be kept safe, a transcription tool with robust redaction features becomes essential. Automated redaction capabilities will ensure compliance with data protection laws and prevent unauthorized access.


This technique allows an AI transcription tool to distinguish between different speakers, attributing spoken words to specific individuals. In legal proceedings, like depositions, diarization is vital in order to achieve a precise transcription. Achieving a low error rate, say 1%, will ensure accurate attribution of spoken words to individuals. This accuracy is critical for reliable legal documentation and case preparation.

Data Residency, Usage and Compliance

Based on your requirements, you may need to consider factors such as data residency, and compliance with regulations like HIPAA. In the healthcare sector, where patient privacy is essential, compliance with regulations like HIPAA is non-negotiable. Transcription tools must adhere to strict data residency requirements, ensuring that patient information is stored and processed within the specified geographical boundaries to comply with regulatory standards.

Processing Time

You will need to evaluate the time it takes for the tool to process transcripts based on your workflow requirements. In call center operations, where quick responses and real-time data are crucial, a transcription tool with swift processing capabilities is imperative. Reduced processing time ensures that transcriptions are available promptly, contributing to a seamless workflow and enhancing customer service efficiency.


Define your budget and choose a pricing model that aligns with your operational needs – per token, per minute, or a flat fee. A startup with budget constraints might opt for a per-minute pricing model for occasional transcription needs. On the other hand, a large enterprise with consistent and high-volume transcription requirements might find a flat fee model more cost-effective, providing predictability in budget planning.

Hosting Options

Decide between self-hosted or service provider-deployed options, making sure to take into account hosting costs and hosting requirements. These can add up quickly! A tech company with strict security protocols and specific infrastructure requirements may choose a self-hosted solution for transcription. This grants them control over data security and customization. Conversely, a smaller business might prefer the convenience of a service provider-deployed option, relying on the provider's infrastructure and expertise.

Transcript Editing

Consider if your users need to be able to edit transcripts. The editing feature in AI transcription tools empowers them to refine and modify transcriptions, adding flexibility and precision to the generated content. In a medical context, if complex terms are initially transcribed inaccurately, the editing feature lets professionals quickly correct errors. This ensures the final document accurately captures the discussion's intricacies, maintaining precision in medical documentation and allowing healthcare practitioners to confidently rely on the transcript.


Selecting the right AI transcription tool involves a comprehensive understanding of your requirements and careful consideration of various factors. By adopting a strategic and analytical approach, product managers can navigate the complexities of the selection process, ensuring the chosen tool seamlessly integrates into their client's workflow.

If you want to learn more about the 8 tools we examined alongside the non-negotiable criteria outlined above, click here

Read more
Community posts


Want to learn more?

Let’s start collaborating on your most complex business problems, today.